Status of bugs: Difference between revisions

From Octave
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
 
(39 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
To report a bug, please use the [https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?group=octave bug tracker].
{{Warning|This page is outdated and no longer maintained. Please use the [https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?group=octave bug tracker].}}


This page is intended to allow those developers without the authority to change the status of bugs on bug tracker to point out bugs that have been fixed, or other suggested status changes, to those who do have authority to update bug tracker.  The goal is that this will be a short list, which is easier for the core developers to scan than the entire bug tracker list.  Currently, it is just Lachlan's thoughts on the 50 or so "Patch submitted" bugs.
This page is intended to allow those developers without the authority to change the status of bugs on bug tracker to point out bugs that have been fixed, or other suggested status changes, to those who do have authority to update bug tracker.  The goal is that this will be a short list, which is easier for the core developers to scan than the entire bug tracker list.  Currently, it is just Lachlan's thoughts on the 50 or so "Patch submitted" bugs.
Line 7: Line 7:
"Types" are chosen so that importance is typically decreasing if sorted by type: C=crash, E=error (wrong result), M=gives error on code Matlab accepts, O=bug in existing Octave functionality that is not part of Matlab, P=performance, X=extension (request to accept code Matlab doesn't accept).)
"Types" are chosen so that importance is typically decreasing if sorted by type: C=crash, E=error (wrong result), M=gives error on code Matlab accepts, O=bug in existing Octave functionality that is not part of Matlab, P=performance, X=extension (request to accept code Matlab doesn't accept).)


==Bugs==
{|class="wikitable sortable"
{|class="wikitable sortable"
!Bug ID !! Status !! Suggested action !! Type !! comments
!Bug ID !! Status !! Suggested action !! Type !! comments
|-
|-
|[https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?31626 31626] || Patch || Apply patch || X
|{{bug|31626}} || Patch ||   || X || ''Can't run odetest.m, "error: handles to nested functions are not yet supported''
''error: called from''
''odetest at line 18 column 20''
''ode_test_script at line 5 column 6"''
|-
|-
|[https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?32008 32008] || Patch || N/C || M || Needs more documentation so a committer can understand it thoroughly
|{{bug|32008}} || Patch || N/C || M || Needs more documentation so a committer can understand it thoroughly
|-
|-
|[https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?32088 32088] || Patch || "In progress" || || Existing patch does not meet requirements
<!-- {{bug|32839}} || Patch || N/C || O || I (Lachlan) don't understand pkg build / install
|-  -->
|<strike> {{bug|33523}} </strike> || Ready for test || Review patch || M || ''Seems to work fine with patch''
|-
|{{bug|36372}} || Patch || See if "reverse ordinal" is useful || P,X || Patch fails to apply to dev- "5 out of 5 hunks failed". Which version failed? The latest patch seems to work for me -- Lachlan
Newest patch works fine (philip)
|-
|{{bug|36646}} || Patch || "In progress"? || M || The patches fix some statistical tests but not all.  No progress for two years.
|-
|{{bug|41512}} || Open || Review patch || M ||
|-
|{{bug|42705}} || Patch || Review patch || O || Patch will need polishing after approval-in-principle
|-
|<strike> {{bug|42850}} </strike> || Fixed || Review patch || C ||''The example in OP works after this patch''
|-
|<strike> {{bug|43511}} </strike> || Patch || Review patch || E ||''Fixes the bug''
|-
|-
<!-- |32839 || Patch || N/C || O || I (Lachlan) don't understand pkg build / install
|{{bug|43925}} || Ready for test || Review patch || e || Patch also fixes {{bug|44498}} ''Patch applies + builds fine, had no time to test yet''
|- -->
|-
|[https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?32885 32885] || Patch || Review latest patch || E || Patch is simple..
|{{bug|44498}} || None || see {{bug|43925}} || e || Disregard patch; use patch for {{bug|43925}}.
|-
|-
|[https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?32924 32924] || Patch || "Postponed" || E || Jordi was going to fix this in 2011.  Should re-allocated to "None"?
|{{bug|45219}} || None || Review patch || M ||
|-
|-
|[https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?33503 33503] || Patch || "closed" || -- || This is just a matter of roundoff
|{{bug|45654}} || Open || Review patch || O || Patch will need polishing after approval-in-principle
|-
|-
|[https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?34363 34363] || Patch || "None" || P || All supplied patches have been applied
|}
 
==Breakpoint bugs==
{|class="wikitable sortable"
!Bug ID !! Fixed? !! comments
|-
|-
|[https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?34624 34624] || Patch || "Duplicate"? || O || Duplicate of #44095?
|{{bug|33411}} || No || Patch supplied ''See comment in bug report''
|-
|-
|[https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?36372 36372] || Patch || See if "reverse ordinal" is useful || P,X ||  
|<strike> {{bug|34804}} </strike> || Yes || Patch supplied ''Patch works fine''
|-
|-
|[https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?36646 36646] || Patch || "In progress"? || M || The patches fix some statistical tests but not all.  No progress for two years.
|{{bug|41514}} || No || I tried the patch and that works fine.
|-
|<strike> {{bug|41540}} </strike> || Yes || Patch supplied
|-
|{{bug|41845}} || Almost || Must use dbstop syntax, but functionality is there
|-
|-
|}
|}
[[Category:Outdated pages]]

Latest revision as of 01:45, 17 October 2019

Warning icon.svg
This page is outdated and no longer maintained. Please use the bug tracker.

This page is intended to allow those developers without the authority to change the status of bugs on bug tracker to point out bugs that have been fixed, or other suggested status changes, to those who do have authority to update bug tracker. The goal is that this will be a short list, which is easier for the core developers to scan than the entire bug tracker list. Currently, it is just Lachlan's thoughts on the 50 or so "Patch submitted" bugs.

N/C means no change.

"Types" are chosen so that importance is typically decreasing if sorted by type: C=crash, E=error (wrong result), M=gives error on code Matlab accepts, O=bug in existing Octave functionality that is not part of Matlab, P=performance, X=extension (request to accept code Matlab doesn't accept).)

Bugs[edit]

Bug ID Status Suggested action Type comments
#31626 Patch X Can't run odetest.m, "error: handles to nested functions are not yet supported

error: called from 

odetest at line 18 column 20
ode_test_script at line 5 column 6"
#32008 Patch N/C M Needs more documentation so a committer can understand it thoroughly
#33523 Ready for test Review patch M Seems to work fine with patch
#36372 Patch See if "reverse ordinal" is useful P,X Patch fails to apply to dev- "5 out of 5 hunks failed". Which version failed? The latest patch seems to work for me -- Lachlan

Newest patch works fine (philip)

#36646 Patch "In progress"? M The patches fix some statistical tests but not all. No progress for two years.
#41512 Open Review patch M
#42705 Patch Review patch O Patch will need polishing after approval-in-principle
#42850 Fixed Review patch C The example in OP works after this patch
#43511 Patch Review patch E Fixes the bug
#43925 Ready for test Review patch e Patch also fixes #44498 Patch applies + builds fine, had no time to test yet
#44498 None see #43925 e Disregard patch; use patch for #43925.
#45219 None Review patch M
#45654 Open Review patch O Patch will need polishing after approval-in-principle

Breakpoint bugs[edit]

Bug ID Fixed? comments
#33411 No Patch supplied See comment in bug report
#34804 Yes Patch supplied Patch works fine
#41514 No I tried the patch and that works fine.
#41540 Yes Patch supplied
#41845 Almost Must use dbstop syntax, but functionality is there
Retrieved from "https://wiki.octave.org/wiki/index.php?title=Status_of_bugs&oldid=12304"